The Regular Public Meeting of the Mount
Olive Township Council was called to Order at 7:59 pm by Council
President Greenbaum with the Pledge of Allegiance.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE & MOMENT OF REFLECTION for all those who
have and continue to protect our freedoms and our way of life.
OPEN PUBLIC MEETINGS ACT ANNOUNCEMENT
According to the Open Public Meetings Act, adequate notice of this
meeting has been given to the Mount Olive Chronicle. Notice has
been posted at the Municipal Building, 204 Flanders-Drakestown
Road, Mount Olive Township, New Jersey and notices were sent
to those requesting the same.
ROLL CALL Present: Mr. Buell, Mr. Rattner, Mrs. Labow, Mr. Tepper,
Mr. Tobey, Mr. Perkins, Mr. Greenbaum
Absent: None
Also Present: David Scapicchio, Mayor; William Sohl, Business
Administrator;
John Dorsey, Township Attorney; Lisa Lashway, Township Clerk; Sherry Jenkins,
CFO
President Greenbaum: At this point I’d like to call Kathy
Murphy up to the podium with respect to the Public Hearing on Green
Acres on the Dog Park at Turkey Brook.
Mrs. Kathy Murphy: Good evening. Some time ago, our Animal Control
Officer Willie Cirone had floated the idea of having a dog park
at Turkey Brook. We had made some decisions as to where a dog park
could be located, and with that it means a change in the Master
Plan for Turkey Brook Park. Under Green Acres regulations we’re
required to have a Public Hearing. We had to do a thirty-day notice
and a legal notice of the Hearing. All of the information was posted
at Turkey Brook Park, and was also available in the Clerk’s
office for public review. So far everybody has been very positive
to my knowledge about the dog park. We have it posted on a map
here for anybody to see now, it’s in yellow, highlighted
in yellow on the map of Turkey Brook there. The original location
on the Master Plan was to have a ninety foot baseball diamond there,
but subsequently we have found that we can’t irrigate that
spot. Based on that issue and irrigation being very important for
a baseball field, we decided that it would be more appropriate
to try to relocate the baseball field, which is not concrete yet
as to where it will be located. In the meantime, that would free
up space if we wanted to put the dog park there. So far the Council
obviously has been very supportive of this and has committed funds
for the fence that goes around the dog park. We have a letter from
the Park Development Committee that’s in favor of moving
the dog park, and we’ve made it aware to different groups
through the Recreation Organizations, Recreation Committee, Open
Space Committee, no objections really have been raised. It would
provide to the public a means to be active with their dogs, and
give Turkey Brook a wider base of activity for the public that
is not solely sports related. We were hoping Mr. Cirone could be
here tonight, but he’s now off fighting forest fires in Montana.
Mr. Rattner: How did I know that?
Mrs. Murphy: Go figure. At any rate we are providing this opportunity
for the public which will be recorded and transcribed and sent
off to Green Acres.
President Greenbaum: At this point in time I would open it up
to anyone from the public who wishes to be heard on this particular
item. Seeing none, I close it to the public. Any Council comment?
Seeing none, thank you very much.
Mrs. Murphy: Okay, thank you.
Mr. Sohl: Thank you Kathy.
Questions on Bill List?
President Greenbaum: Okay, we’re up to questions on the
Bill List which we’ve already dealt with. We’re going
to move right into Approval of Minutes of Previous Meetings. Mr.
Tepper, do you want to move the Minutes please?
APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETINGS
June 26, 2007 PM – All Present
June 26, 2007 CS – All Present
July 10, 2007 WS – Mr. Tobey absent
July 10, 2007 PM – Mr. Tobey absent
July 24, 2007 WS – All Present
July 24, 2007 CS – All Present
Mr. Tepper: Yes, Mr. President, I move for approval of the Minutes
of June 26, 2007 PM, June 26, 2007 CS, July 10, 2007 WS, July 10,
2007 PM, July 24, 2007 WS, and July 24, 2007 CS.
Mrs. Labow: Second.
President Greenbaum: Moved and seconded. Are there any deletions,
changes, modifications, or questions? Seeing none, Roll Call.
ROLL CALL: Passed Unanimously with the exception of Mr. Tobey
who abstained from both July 10th Sessions.
CORRESPONDENCE
LETTERS FROM RESIDENTS / ORGANIZATIONS
1. Letter received July 22, 2007, from Mitch Weintraub regarding
the Lights at Russ Nagle Field.
2. Letter received July 30, 2007, from Charles L. Smith III, Area
Director of Government and Community Affairs regarding Northwest
Digital Conversion.
3. Letter received August 2, 2007 from the New Jersey State League
of Municipalities regarding a League Seminar of Effective Records
Management: The Cornerstone of Local Government Operations.
RESOLUTIONS / ORDINANCE / CORRESPONDENCE OTHER TOWNS
4. Resolution received July 2, 2007, from the Township of Pequannock
regarding Support of Senate Bill S-2507 / Lyme Disease.
5. Ordinance received July 23, 2007, from Washington Township
regarding Land Use.
6. Public Notice received July 11, 2007, from the Hackettstown
Planning Board regarding a Special Meeting for the Master Plan
Reexamination Report.
7. Resolution received July 26, 2007, from the Township of Parsippany-Troy
Hills regarding Cost of a State Wide Gypsy Moth Control Program.
8. Resolution received July 27, 2007, from the Township of Hamilton
regarding State Wide Gypsy Moth Program.
9. Public Meeting Notice received from Tina Marie Green of Roxbury
regarding Board of Adjustment Agenda, Subject: Islamic Center of
Morris County.
10. Public Hearing Notice received July 27, 2007 regarding the
verified petition of East Coast Oakwood Apartments Sewage L.L.C.
for approval of a transfer of control of Oakwood Village Sewerage
Associates, L.L.C.
11. Resolution No. 2007-83 received August 3, 2007 from the Borough
of Hopewell in support of Remedial Legislation to Authorize a Library
Cap Exception.
MUA / MSA
12. List of Allocations received July 9, 2007, from the Musconetcong
Sewerage Authority regarding participating Municipalities in the
4.31 MGD Water Pollution Control Plant.
13. Regular Meeting Minutes of the Musconetcong Sewerage Authority
received August 3, 2007 regarding the July 11th Meeting.
DOT / DEP / LOI / HIGHLANDS
14. Letter received July 2, 2007, from Roxbury Enterprises, LLC
regarding Marveland Farms, expansion of topsoil operation.
15. Seminar Information received July 23, 2007, from the State
of New Jersey, Department of Environmental Protection regarding
Historic Preservation.
16. Notice of Technical Incompleteness received July 23, 2007,
from the State of New Jersey, Department of Environmental Protection
regarding Glasson – Single Family Home, Block 5300, Lots
27 & 28 (Courtney Drive)
17. Letter received July 26, 2007, from the State of New Jersey,
Department of Environmental Protection regarding Letter of Interpretation – Line
Verification for Applicant: The Rockefeller Group Block 105, Lot
1; Block 106, Lot 3; and Block 202, Lot 1 (250, 30 Continental
Drive and 2000 International Drive, Mount Olive)
18. Letter received July 27, 2007, from Civil Engineering regarding
Notice of Technical Incompleteness Applicant: Glasson – Single
Family Home Block 5300, Lots 27 and 28 (Courtney Drive)
19. Letter received July 27, 2007, from the Township of Hardyston
regarding the Impact of the Highlands Act on Plan Endorsement.
20. Letter received July 27, 2007, from the State of New Jersey,
Department of Environmental Protection regarding Proposed Amendment
to the Atlantic County, Cape May County, Ocean County, Lower Delaware,
Monmouth County, Middlesex County, Lower Raritan / Middlesex, Tri-County,
Upper Raritan, Upper Delaware, Northeast and Sussex County Water
Quality Management Plans for Pathogen Impairment to 75 Lakes.
21. Letter received July 20, 2007, from the State of New Jersey,
Department of Environmental Protection regarding NJ Vasa Home Water
System permit application.
22. Letter received July 28, 2007, from Richard J. Hoff, Jr.,
Esquire of Flaster Greenberg Attorneys at Law regarding Highlands
Exemption – Block 4400, Lot 79, Mount Olive Township Morris
Chase (a.k.a. Dyrham Wood, formerly Golden Hills).
23. Letter received August 1, 2007, from the State of New Jersey,
Department of Environmental Protection regarding County and Municipal
Green Acres Projects Funding Categories and Levels.
MORRIS COUNTY
24. Minutes received June 21, 2007, from the Morris County Planning
Board regarding the meeting of June 21, 2007.
25. Computed Tax rate information received July 23, 2007, from
the Morris County Board of Taxation regarding Mount Olive Township.
LEGISLATIVE REPRESENTATIVES
26. E-mail received June 29, 2007, from Congressman Frelinghuysen
regarding Host of Town Hall Meeting, Air Noise Concerns, Preservation
of Freedom of Speech, National Homeowners Month, Highlands, Great
Swamp Funding Pass House, and Andean Trade Agreement Approved.
UTILITES
27. Letter received July 26, 2007, from Comcast regarding the
recent listing in Black Enterprise for one of the top 15 best companies
for workforce diversity.
28. Letter received July 26, 2007, from New Jersey Natural Gas
regarding list of disconnected residential customers.
29. Notice of Public Hearing received August 1, 2007 from Pivotal
Utility Holdings, Inc. D/B/A Elizabethtown Gas regarding the 2007/2008
Annual Compliance Filing for the Universal Service Fund and Lifeline
Program Components within the Societal Benefits Charge Rate Pursuant
to N.J.S.A. 48:2-21 and N.J.S.A. 48:-21.1.
30. Letter received August 2, 2007 from Jersey Central Power and
Light regarding the Annual Universal Service Fund Compliance Filing
Jersey Central Power & Light Company Docket No. EX00020091.
President Greenbaum: There are thirty pieces of Correspondence
on the Agenda this evening. Does anyone wish to discuss any particular
piece of Correspondence? Seeing none, we’ll move right into
Ordinances for Public Hearing.
ORDINANCE FOR PUBLIC HEARING
President Greenbaum: We have one Ordinance this evening, entitled:
Ord. #36-2007 An Ordinance of the Township of Mount Olive Authorizing
a Revision to the Code of the Township of Mount Olive, Chapter
102 Entitled “Document, Fees for Copies of” Article
II Entitled “Open Public Records Fees” Section 102-3B
Entitled “Designation of Custodian and Deputy Custodians
of Municipal Records” to Create a New Subsection (6) Entitled “Construction
Code Official.”
President Greenbaum: Does anyone from the public wish to be heard
on Ord. #36-2007? Seeing none, I close it to the public and ask
Mr. Buell to please move this for approval.
Mr. Buell: Thank you, I move Ord. #36-2007 for final passage.
Mrs. Labow: Second.
President Greenbaum: Moved and seconded. Is there any Council
comment? Roll Call please.
ROLL CALL: Passed Unanimously
President Greenbaum: Ordinance #36-2007 has passed on second reading
and I hereby direct the Clerk to forward a copy of same to the
Mayor and publish the notice of adoption as required by law.
ORDINANCES FOR FIRST READING – August 21, 2007
President Greenbaum: Ordinances for First Reading this evening
we have two, with the second reading to be August 21, 2007. The
first Ordinance is Ord. #37-2007 entitled:
Ord. #37-2007 An Ordinance of the Township of Mount Olive Granting
Permission to Applied Wastewater Management, Inc. to Construct,
Install and Operate Equipment, Pipes and Mains for the Operation
of a Wastewater Collection and Treatment System Within Certain
Designated Areas of the Township of Mount Olive Commonly Referred
to as “Morris Chase.”
President Greenabaum: Mr. Perkins, can you please move that for
First Reading?
Mr. Perkins: Yes, Mr. President, I move that Ord. #37-2007 be
introduced by title and passed on first reading and that a Meeting
be held on August 21, 2007 at 7:30 p.m. at the Municipal Building,
204 Flanders-Drakestown Road, Mount Olive, NJ for a public hearing
consideration of said reading and passage of said ordinance and
that the Clerk be directed to publish, post and make available
such ordinance in accordance with the requirements of law.
Mrs. Labow: Second.
President Greenabaum: Is there any Council discussion? Roll Call.
ROLL CALL: Passed Unanimously
President Greenabaum: Next Ordinance for First Reading, do you
have a copy of it? Alright, here it is. That’s the first
one, okay yes I got it. It’s Ord. # 38-2007 entitled:
Ord. #38-2007 An Ordinance Granting Permission and Consent to
Applied Wastewater Management, Inc., to Construct, Install and
Operate Equipment, Wells, Pipes and Mains for a Water Supply System
within Certain Designated Areas of the Township of Mount Olive
Commonly Known as “Morris Chase” and “Morris
Hunt.”
President Greenbaum: Mr. Perkins, would you do us the honor of
moving that as well?
Mr. Perkins: Yes, Mr. President, I move that Ord. #38-2007 be
introduced by title and passed on first reading and that a Meeting
be held on August 21, 2007 at 7:30 p.m. at the Municipal Building,
204 Flanders-Drakestown Road, Mount Olive, NJ for a public hearing
consideration of said reading and passage of said ordinance and
that the Clerk be directed to publish, post and make available
such ordinance in accordance with the requirements of law.
President Greenbaum: Is there a second?
Mr. Buell: Second.
President Greenbaum: Just so the public is aware, although it’s
not on the Agenda the Ordinance itself has been made available
and it’s on the table. It was in our package for the Workshop
and had been removed by me, and then put back on the Agenda this
evening for the Public Meeting. Is there any Council comment or
discussion with respect to Ord. #38-2007? Mr. Rattner.
Mr. Rattner: Yes, as I socialized with a couple of people there
are a couple of minor details in there I just need clarification
on. However, they’re not enough to make us go forward and
I’m sure I can get the answers before the public meeting.
President Greenbaum: Any other discussion? Mr. Perkins.
Mr. Perkins: Thank you Mr. President. This Ordinance embodies
months, quite frankly some years of investigative work and research
by our Township Attorney, Mr. Dorsey. I would like to personally
thank him for his help and guidance in getting this done. Thank
you Mr. President.
President Greenbaum: Any other Council discussion? Roll Call please.
ROLL CALL: Passed Unanimously
CONSENT RESOLUTIONS AGENDA:
Resolutions on the Consent Agenda List are considered to be routine
and non-controversial by the Township Council and will be approved
by one motion (one vote). There will be no separate discussion
or debate on each of these resolutions except for the possibility
of brief clarifying statements that may be offered. If one or more
Council member requests, any individual resolution on the Consent
Agenda may be removed from the Consent Agenda List and acted on
separately.
CONSENT RESOLUTIONS
1. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township of Mount
Olive Authorizing the Township Attorney to Proceed to Collect Connection
Fees/Service Fees Relative to Lot 11, Block 3100.
2. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township of Mount
Olive Authorizing the Renewals of Membership in the Morris County
Joint Insurance Fund for 2008-2011.
3. Resolution, Application and Agreement with NJDOT for State
Aid for the Resurfacing of Flanders-Bartley Road.
4. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township of Mount
Olive Awarding a Contract to Musco Sports Lighting, LLC for Lighting
Materials for Russ Nagle Field.
5. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township of Mount
Olive Authorizing the Purchase of Uniforms for the DPW Employees
from Alliance Promotional Products.
6. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township of Mount
Olive Authorizing a Change Order i.e. a Reduction in the Contract
of A.P.S. Contracting, Inc., Relative to the New DPW Garage.
7. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township of Mount
Olive Awarding a Contract to Oriental Pacific Maintenance for Cleaning
Services of the Municipal Building and Senior Center.
8. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township of Mount
Olive to Cancel the August and November, 2007 Taxes on Block 3201,
Lot 56 for Disabled Veteran Declared 1000% Totally & Permanently
Disabled by the Tax Assessor.
9. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township of Mount
Olive Authorizing the Cancellation of a Grant Balance.
10. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township Mount Olive
Requesting Approval from the Director of the Division of Local
Government Services for Insertion of a Specific Item of Revenue
into the 2007 Municipal Budget ($1,635.18 for Donation – Lion’s
Club).
11. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township Mount Olive
Authorizing a Chapter 159 Budget Amendment in the 2007 Budget for
the Child Safety and Child Booster Seat Incentive Grant for $5,000.00.
12. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township of Mount
Olive Authorizing the Use of Various Purchasing Contracts.
13. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township of Mount
Olive Authorizing a Contract with Mathew Krauser for Appraisal
of Block 2700 Lots 51 and 52.05 and Block 3204 Lot 1.
14. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township of Mount
Olive Authorizing the Continued Emergency Stabilization of the
Seward House.
15. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township of Mount
Olive Closing Edgewood Place on August 12, 2007, between 12 pm
and 8 pm for the purpose of Holding a Block Party.
President Greenbaum: Does anyone wish to have any of the Resolutions
removed from the Consent Resolutions Agenda? I can tell you that
numbers 14 and 16, 16 is the added Resolution with respect to the
materials for the Seward House. They are going to be put on Non
Consent. Are there any other Resolutions that any Council member
wishes to have removed? Seeing none, I would ask that Mr. Tobey
move the Consent Resolutions Agenda.
Mr. Tobey: I move Consent Resolutions 1-13 and number 15.
Mr. Perkins: Second.
President Greenbaum: Moved and seconded. Is there anyone from
the public who wishes to be heard on any of the Resolutions on
the Consent Agenda? Seeing none, I close it to the public. Does
any Council member have any brief clarifying statements? Seeing
none, Roll Call.
PUBLIC PORTION ON CONSENT RESOLUTIONS - none
COUNCIL COMMENTS ON CONSENT RESOLUTIONS - none
ROLL CALL: Passed unanimously with the exception Mr. Greenbaum
abstained on number 2.
RESOLUTIONS NON CONSENT
President Greenbaum: We’re going to start with number 14,
which is entitled:
14. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township of Mount
Olive Authorizing the Continued Emergency Stabilization of the
Seward House.
President Greenbaum: Mr. Tepper do you want to move that please?
Mr. Tepper: I move Non Consent Resolution #14.
Mr. Perkins: Second.
President Greenbaum: Moved and seconded. Does anyone from the
Public wish to be heard? Mr. McDonnell please state your name and
address for the record.
PUBLIC PORTION ON INDIVIDUAL RESOLUTIONS
Mr. Rattner: …different title…
President Greenbaum: Oh we do. One second Mr. McDonnell, just
let me look.
Mr. Rattner: Does Kathy have it because I caught something this
afternoon.
President Greenbaum: The title is Resolution of the Township Council
of the Township of Mount Olive Authorizing the Continued Extraordinary
Un-specifiable Work for the Stabilization of the Seward House.
Ned McDonnell, Budd Lake: I’m just wondering, this contract,
why has it not gone out for bid?
President Greenbaum: That was discussed at our last meeting. Because
of the nature of the work, we’ve had legal counsel that the
type of work is very specific and did not require us to go out
to bid on that type of work which was historical. Parts of the
work that are not historical such as the re-shingling of the roof
will actually go out to bid.
Mr. McDonnell: Well I understand maybe legally that’s not
necessary, but was there any attempt made to find other contractors
that have the expertise to do this type of work?
President Greenbaum: Kathy, can you answer that question please?
Mrs. Murphy: Yes, as far as the masonry portion we had actually
sent out an RFP and we got one man who was very qualified, but
his quote was more than double what Bogart had quoted us. For other
work on the carpentry etc., we have looked for other carpenters
in the past. One came in with a higher bid, and others declined
to bid. The most unusual part about this of course is as we continue
with this work there are surprises all the time. It’s very
difficult to actually come up with a very specific bid based on
the nature of this building and the condition that it’s in.
So that’s made it difficult for us and in large part this
was a continuation of that stabilization. You can’t just
have an ordinary person do it. They could drop that roof on their
head and be injured.
Mr. McDonnell: Yes, I understand the special nature and I’m
certainly in favor of the house being stabilized and repaired.
What kind of controls, and this you know it looks like it’s
about 500 hours which is like twelve weeks of work. Is this an
open ended contract?
Mr. Dorsey: No it’s not open ended. It has specific dollar
amounts for different… I think there are three different
aspects of the contract that Bogart will do, and he does it specifically
under the supervision in accordance with plans developed by Mr.
Hitchens who is an AIA, a licensed architect of the State of New
Jersey.
Mr. McDonnell: And he will be monitoring this as the work goes
on?
Mr. Dorsey: That’s my understanding, is that not right Kathy?
President Greenbaum: That I can tell you that the Council has
specifically been in the house to monitor the nature of the work
which has been performed to date. I have been in the house, I think,
on three different occasions during the course of the stabilization,
and what I suggest because you’ve shown an interest, is that
the next time we’re brought through on a progress tour that
you be included. It’s really very fascinating to see the
progress as it goes along. He’s made incredible progress
for the amount of money that was spent.
Mr. McDonnell: I’d certainly like to be included because
I am interested in the house and I think it’s a very worthwhile
endeavor.
President Greenbaum: Mr. Sohl did you have something?
Mr. Sohl: Yes, and in fact this specialty work followed then by
the actual roofing which will be bid, once that is done we should
be at a point where we can do certain open houses not on a limited
basis, but on a much more general basis.
President Greenbaum: Ned, the Administration and Council have
really been walking in lockstep with respect to this particular
project. We’ve always thought that what we needed to do was
to bring it to a point where we can get others with donation dollars
to participate and finish the project, but the town needed to take
the laboring work because of the condition of the building, in
terms of it being so unstable, to get it to a point where someone
could come in and look at it and say, “you know what this
is a project because of it’s location, because of the historical
value that it’s worth, and because of the use that the Township
could get from that building, this is a project that is worthwhile.” That’s
started to happen at this point where we’ve gotten other
people who are interested. Kathy is continuing to work that project.
As I said, I’m going to make sure that you are included in
the notification of the next time that we’re going to go
through that house so that you yourself can look at it and say, “wow.” It’s
really a fairly incredible project that is going to benefit the
town, especially because of its location being at the front of
Turkey Brook Park.
Mr. McDonnell: Absolutely, I completely agree with you. Thank
you.
President Greenbaum: Okay, thank you. Is there anyone else from
the public who wishes to be heard? Seeing none, I close it to the
public. Is there any other comment from Council? Roll Call please.
COUNCIL COMMENTS ON INDIVIDUAL RESOLUTIONS - none
ROLL CALL – Passed Unanimously
President Greenbaum: We’re up to Non Consent Resolution
number 16 entitled:
16. Resolution of the Township Council of the Township of Mount
Olive Authorizing Materials and Equipment for Continued Emergency
Stabilization of the Seward House.
President Greenbaum: Mrs. Labow can you move that please?
Mrs. Labow: Yes, I move Resolution number 16.
Mr. Rattner: Second.
President Greenbaum: It’s been moved and seconded. Anyone
from the public wish to be heard? I close it to the public. Any
further Council comment? Roll Call please.
ROLL CALL: Passed Unanimously
MOTIONS
1. Approval of RA#2204 for the Mt. Olive High School Marching
Band and RA#2205 for Special Olympics NJ.
President Greenbaum: Mrs. Labow do you want to move the Raffle
Applications?
Mrs. Labow: Thank you Mr. President. Approval of Raffle Application
#2204 for the Mt. Olive High School Marching Band and Raffle Application
#2205 for Special Olympics NJ.
Mr. Buell: Second.
President Greenbaum: Moved and seconded. Any discussion? Roll
Call please.
ROLL CALL: Passed Unanimously
2. Approval of a Peddler’s Permit for Elaine Brown.
Mr. Perkins: Yes, I move for approval of Peddler’s Permit
for Elaine Brown.
Mrs. Labow: Second.
President Greenbaum: Moved and seconded. Roll Call please.
ROLL CALL: Passed Unanimously with the exception Mr. Tepper voted
no.
3. Bill List
Mr. Rattner: Mr. President I move the Bill List as submitted.
Mr. Perkins: Second.
President Greenbaum: It’s been moved and seconded. Any discussion?
Did you have anything this evening Mr. Russell? Mr. McDonnell?
You do have something on the Bill List? Why don’t you come
up?
Mr. McDonnell: I apologize for not asking ahead of time. Page
four, Sam’s Club membership fees. It looks like we’ve
got three memberships. Why do we have three?
President Greenbaum: Sherry?
Mrs. Jenkins: We have different people from different departments
that are authorized to go. We used to have a much larger list and
I consolidated it as much as I could so that we weren’t paying
fees for people that didn’t need to go.
Mr. McDonnell: And you have to pay separately?
Mrs. Jenkins: Yes. I have argued this point I can’t even
tell you for how long, and my staff has assured me that we have
to pay this way. We used to have a larger list and I’ve consolidated
it down as much as I can.
Mr. McDonnell: Good. Thank you.
President Greenbaum: Thank you.
Mrs. Labow: Mr. Greenbaum? I just wanted to tell Ned that for
the Parent’s Club we argued with them too because they would
only let us have two people, and there are four of us.
Mrs. Jenkins: So you know what I mean.
Mrs. Labow: Yes, we went through the same exact thing and we’re
not for profit.
Mr. McDonnell: Okay. On the top of the page, beach supplies, these
were supplies that would not be budgeted to the Recreation Utility?
Mrs. Jenkins: Ned, these are coming out of the Municipal Beach
Budget.
Mr. McDonnell: I understand they are, but is there a reason they
come out of that and not the Recreation Utility?
Mr. Sohl: That’s what they’re used for. What are they?
Mrs. Jenkins: Well, I mean, I don’t know how to answer that
for you. That’s really a question for Jill in terms of what
comes out of her beach budget as opposed to the utility. I will
follow up for you.
Mr. McDonnell: See, we’re back to the same question I asked
once before. It seems like the person that’s using the supplies
is also the person that’s authorizing whether it comes out
of the utility or not. I don’t see where there’s an
oversight there as to who determines what is regular operating
budget, and what is coming out of the utility. I’m not suggesting
that there’s anything wrong, but I think that the person
that benefits should not be the person, not really benefits, but
looking at their own budget. I don’t think that they should
be the person really making the determination as to whether it’s
budgeted to their budget or not. Just as a good check and balance.
Mr. Sohl: Yes, I don’t know how to, I mean without hiring
more people to oversee other people.
Mr. McDonnell: Maybe just an explanation of what the supplies
are. I mean I’m sure there’s been some thought into
this.
Mrs. Jenkins: Yes, I’ll speak to Jill to find out how she
differentiates between what she’s charging here versus there.
Mr. Sohl: I mean clearly during the course of the summer, there
is a need for supplies.
Mr. McDonnell: Oh, I agree.
President Greenbaum: Bill, I think the appropriate response is
that the question has been raised on several occasions with respect
to how Jill classifies her expenses. We’re going to need
to get an explanation from Jill as to how she makes the determination
as to what comes out of the utility and what comes out of her general
budget so that we can have appropriate checks and balances with
respect to her expenditures.
Mr. McDonnell: You said it better than I could say it.
President Greenbaum: Thank you.
Mr. McDonnell: On page 11, toward the bottom of the page, Kenny
Products Inc., Vinyl ID Badge Holders. $500 worth of Badge holders,
what is that for?
Mr. McDonnell: I believe it’s on the purchase order and
I will go through and pull it out for you. I don’t know it
off of the top of my head.
Mr. McDonnell: Thank you.
Mrs. Jenkins: Okay.
President Greenbaum: Thank you very much Mr. McDonnell. Next meeting,
explanation from Jill as to how she designates… Any other
questions from Council with respect to the Bill List? Roll Call
please.
ROLL CALL: Passed Unanimously
ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS
President Greenbaum: Any further Administrative matters Mr. Sohl?
Mr. Sohl: Just one question. At the next meeting I believe there
will be two resolutions dealing with tax appeals that Mr. Dorsey
has provided. Is it your pleasure to have Jack Marchione present
for those two?
President Greenbaum: Mr. Dorsey? Yes.
Mr. Sohl: Okay.
President Greenbaum: Thank you. Mayor, any additional Administrative
Matters?
Mayor Scapicchio: None.
OLD BUSINESS
President Greenbaum: Old Business? Mr. Buell.
Mr. Buell: Yes, obviously we are approaching the 2008 budget and
I’ve been thinking about next year which appears to be a
challenging year ahead. I’ve been looking at various meetings
and I think the Council and the Administration with, or Council
with the Administration’s input needs to begin to take a
look at. I’d like to discuss some of them tonight. I’ve
provided an outline of my discussion to you. Some of the things
we’ve already discussed tonight like the Glendale tennis
courts. I think that’s the kind of appropriate discussion
we need to have on all of these items. I’ve broken the outline
up into two areas, and I think the one I want to discuss tonight
is the basis to the challenges to consider to prepare the 2008
budget. I think we should schedule the longer range planning issues
for other meetings since they’re not immediate, but just
to start off. Merit salary Administration. I think that the first
Council Meetings I attended four years ago or three years ago,
we talked about, and this Council adopted the policy that we think
that all salary increases to department heads and middle managers
should be made on a merit basis. Here were are in 2007 and we do
not have a merit salary Administration program for our managers,
and that’s, and I think we need to have that. There are some
members of Council who I have discussed this with in the past who
have said that we shouldn’t grant any salary increases unless
it’s on a merit basis. I’ve been obviously thinking
about this for some time, and in May I sent an e-mail to all of
us sharing my comments. I also shared it with Administration in
terms of what a salary Administration program entails, and what
we need to do to get this thing going. In the first step, really
the guts of it, we need new job descriptions. We need job expectations
based upon the beginning of the period, so that at the end of the
period which is presumably the year, because the salary increases
we’re talking about will be granted to department heads and
middle managers at the first of the year, and yet none of this
exists. Worse is that last November the department heads met with
the Administration as a group starting a collective bargaining
process, I think. They were promised that salary increases would
be considered for them on a meritorious basis. I think at this
point in time we need to get going. It’s a project that I
think is an extremely important project simply because our department
heads are the people who’ve been holding this place together
for the last three years. Most of them are very, very good and
that’s the reason why we’ve been able to survive. I
think we now need to begin to provide them with the recognition
and the tangible rewards in the places where their performance
merits it on an ongoing basis. I think we need to get this program
started. I don’t know whether we can get it in place by January
of this year. I think the policies can be put together. The question
I have is whether or not we can put together the job descriptions
and put together the job expectations that make sense, and then
do the appraisals at the end of this process, which is necessary
for such an important program. The second issue, and again I would
like anybody to chime in at the end of this, I’d like to…
Mr. Rattner: Jim I just have one request. You have 18 items, could
you move it a little bit quick because if we spend this much time
on each one we won’t get out until 11:00. I think the Mayor
had something he wanted to say.
Mayor Scapicchio: You know I can either comment on each one of
the 18 items as Mr. Buell goes along, at the end, or I can comment
as we move forward. Whatever you…
Mr. Rattner: I would prefer that for timing, so that we don’t
end up discussing each one, that we do it all at the end if you
don’t mind.
Mayor Scapicchio: Perfect.
Mr. Buell: Number two, we’re ending the process of the DPW
garage. Hopefully we will occupy that and we will move our trucks
off of the beach this fall some time. Now we have two garages down
at the beach, one of which the original plan was to take it down.
I think that’s the masonry building that sits down there.
The other one was to renovate it, renovate the metal building for
use of the beach in terms of storage. Hopefully since we have sewer
and water at that location we would provide a bathroom facility
and other amenities, such as a concession stand for the people
who use that. I think that the lynchpin of the entire Lake is the
use of that municipal facility. Three is fleet maintenance. I’ve
heard rumors that there are both performance and cost issues related
to the new Penske contract. I know there are cost issues because
we’ve been following the cost, and in some cases we’ve
looked at the out of contract expenses and I think we’re
over on that budget line at this point in time. I’ve heard,
as I said, rumors that there are concerns about performance as
well, and one of the questions I have is is that true? What are
we going to do with the Fleet Maintenance Program? Are we going
to consider bringing this service back inside instead of contracting
it out. Number four is Blue Atlas. I’ve already basically
talked about that when Ron Heymann was here. Again I think at this
point in time, I think it’s very timely that we plan not
only for the use of that field, but what are the long range and
short range plans for that particular field? In addition, there
is that nursery stock that I also talked about and I think we should
consider that at this point in time in some kind of a fashion.
Parking at both Turkey Brook and Flanders Park, Mr. Heymann didn’t
mention those two issues. Now that we’re going to have the
baseball lights at Flanders Park, the parking is going to be inadequate,
more inadequate than it is now, we need to look at what we can
do in terms of parking. We also need to begin to look at the issue
of budgeting for that process. Parking at Turkey Brook Park is
a critical need. When all of those fields are in use, and now that
we’re going to have the dog park and we’re hopefully
going to be using Turkey Brook Park more and more, there are more
and more days when that Park’s parking facilities are inadequate.
One of the operational issues in terms of the Musco contract that
we have not resolved at this point in time is the cost for the
electrical. It’s going to cost us $10,000 a year.
Mr. Tepper: By the way, I spoke to Baseball and they disagreed
with that. I had Musco run up numbers and they are estimating more
in the neighborhood of less than $2,000 based on the number of
times there will be games that will run late. Even presuming that
several start at that time, but they estimated it would be in the
$2,000 bracket.
Mr. Rattner: Let Jim go through because the Mayor asked first
to speak. I’ll put you on the list second.
Mr. Tepper: Sorry, thank you.
Mr. Buell: Number seven is a critical issue. I think it’s
this coming year or the following year that we must meet Storm
Water Management regulations or the new regs and have a place,
or facility, or a process by which we can wash our trucks off when
they come off the roads. We don’t have that in the new DPW
garage. I’m told that we could put it into the DPW garage.
In addition, the Board of Education has the same issue and they
expressed an interest in joining with us to develop such a facility
jointly for the joint use of the Board of Education and the Township.
I think that’s another issue that needs to be discussed.
Recently the Morris County Utility Authority has issued new tough
guidelines in terms of recyclables. It’s been in the newspapers
but I haven’t seen anything in terms of the town reacting
to that. What is our plan to inform the public if they have papers
or recyclables mixed in with their garbage? What is going to be
our reaction? How are we going to handle that issue? We talked
earlier about the movement of the fuel depot which is inadequate
in size, provides us with, if we had a larger facility we could
cut our fuel costs significantly. We’ve also talked about
sharing the fuel depot with the Board of Education, sharing both
the capital costs and the operational costs. That’s an issue
that has disappeared basically from the radar screen. I think we
need to get a backup on the radar screen and begin to look at it.
We all know that the DPW garage costs are overrun. Last time I
heard it was close to $2.5 million although most of us thought
that was going to happen when we entered into the issue of building
the DPW garage. During the last six months, or last three months,
I know a large amount of municipal manpower did much of the site
work at the municipal garage. I’d like to know what that
cost is and what didn’t get done as a result of our employees
being there. Number 12, I think at this point in time to my knowledge
we haven’t done performance appraisals on any employees including
department heads and middle managers. I think it’s an issue
that we really need to get into from a human resource direction.
On a long term Mr. Buell (cont’d): basis some of the things
on my list are that we need to have a meeting to discuss the redevelopment
of the Budd Lake Beach and the Lake. We need to discuss Open Space
because at this point in time I don’t expect that we’re
going to be buying that much open space, and we’ve expressed
that opinion simply because most of the open space that is left
in the Township of Mount Olive is in the Highlands. The whole question
I think we now need to begin to look at is is the three cents that
we’re now collecting in taxes for Open Space appropriate?
How much do we need for development of open space? How much should
we consider actually cutting that cost of the Open Space tax? I
think we need to look at the Recreational Master Plan. I think
the Recreational Master Plan that now exists is a good document,
it documents what Recreational facilities exist, but it doesn’t
talk about realistically what we need to do to develop and when
we’re going to develop additional facilities and when we
need to develop those additional facilities. We also need to look
at the redevelopment of the Park Committee. Now that we’ve
expanded it to cover more than just Turkey Brook Park, we need
additional people coming to the Meetings. I think there have been
additional appointments but those people have not been coming to
that Park Committee Meeting. It’s an important Committee.
It’s important that all of the sports come to that group
because that’s the funnel in which I think a lot of these
decisions, in terms of prioritizing the use of the Open Space funds
for development, will be made. We also should consider shared fleet
maintenance with the Board of Education. We also should consider,
or at least one person or several people have looked at the issue
of having the municipality approach the Board of Education to do
their grounds maintenance. We’ve got the tractors, we’ve
got the equipment, and we can do it better. They do this in Parsippany,
it’s I think something we should consider. And again, we
should be looking at shared services in terms of what services
we can share, and what services we should share with both the Board
of Education and other municipalities.
Mr. Rattner: Okay thank you. I have the Mayor then Mr. Tepper
as far as comments, and I’ll try watching for any other hands
that go up. Mayor?
Mayor Scapicchio: Jim, thanks for the 18 bulleted items that you’d
like us to pay attention to. I guess I’ll try to answer as
many as I can to the best of my ability, and I’ll start with
number one. You talk about Merit Salary Administration Policy for
Department Heads and Middle Mangers. I can tell you that when we
came in here in November, Bill and myself, we were asked to do
evaluations on performance and to propose what I would call merit
/ bonus increases for those department heads and supervisors that
are not represented by the Union. We at that point in time told
both them and the Council that we had not been on board long enough,
nor did we have the experience or the interface time with those
employees to be able to do an accurate evaluation of their performance.
We have prepared and we will be prepared to present to the Council,
a bonus / evaluation report with a recommended merit increase for
those department heads and supervisors that we have the control
over for the 2008 budget cycle. I guess I would ask Sherry since
she sort of represented, or represents the department heads and
the middle managers, to comment if she would like on what their
perspective is, and their thoughts on where we are today.
Mrs. Jenkins: We definitely met as a group with Bill and Dave
when they first came on board. We were well aware that they were
here obviously for a short time, had a lot of issues on their plate,
and didn’t expect that anything would be put into place immediately.
We were certainly hoping that something would be done for 2008,
and that seems to be the case, so we’re very happy with that.
I just want to real quick touch upon the perception that’s
sort of out there that, while there may not have been a formal
review process in place, certainly we interact with the Mayor and
the Administrator on a daily basis. They are well aware of our
work effort and in the event that any problems do arise obviously
they are addressed. So I don’t want the public to think that
there is no oversight and that there is no scrutiny. We definitely
do have that and because there hasn’t been a formal evaluation
completed, it doesn’t mean that they’re not aware of
what’s going on and that they’re not aware of our work
effort. That’s just something that certainly we’re
all concerned about.
Mayor Scapicchio: You know, I’d also like to say to Jim
and the rest of the Council that what we also need to pay attention
to is the fact that we need to prioritize in terms of these 12
or 18 items that Jim now talks about after three and a half years
of being on this Council, in terms of budget prioritization, and
if you take into account the additional pension payments that we
have to pay for 2008 that the State has made us aware of, if you
add into that equation, the already negotiated salary increases
for 2008, we’re looking at about $790,000 in additional payments
that we need to make in 2008 over 2007. That equates to about four
tax points. So the Council, we as an Administration certainly need
to prioritize what we want to do in terms of moving forward. Part
of Jim’s proposal is to reevaluate and restructure the salaries
of the department heads and supervisors moving forward. He suggests
that it’s my responsibility in terms of the Administrative
staff, and the Council’s responsibility in terms of the individuals
in the Clerk’s office. I can tell you that at this point
in time I will not be making any recommendations in terms of major
salary adjustments above the normal increases in the Administrative
staff for 2008, with the exception of the potential of one or two
employees. I think that with the increase that we see moving forward,
I think that that would be irresponsible on my part and I see no
need at this point in time to reevaluate that whole process. DPW
garages at Budd Lake, it would be my inclination to demolish those
buildings rather than renovate them once the DPW operation has
moved over into this new building. We anticipate that this new
building will be ready for use for the winter of 2008, and I will
be making Mayor Scapicchio (cont’d): a proposal, or recommendation
when I present my 2008 budget to the Council. Same thing with item
number three, Fleet Maintenance. Do I want to outsource that? I
do. I do not plan on making a recommendation to bring that in house.
When it comes to number four, Blue Atlas, at this point in time
there are no plans on the Administration’s part for the development
of that Park. We close and retain ownership of that December 31,
2007, so I don’t see any money being needed for that in 2008
with the exception of maybe a small amount of money for planning.
Parking at Flanders Park and Turkey Brook Park. I’m not sure
what Jim really means with respect to that. My take would be that
no matter how much parking you had at recreational facilities,
it is never enough. When you have these programs that are as successful
as ours are you have parents, grandparents, aunts, uncles, brothers,
sisters, all coming to participate in the viewing of those games,
and you will never, ever have enough parking to suit those needs,
no matter how much you plan for. The electrical costs for the lights
at Flanders Park. I’m not sure Jim, do you want to charge
the sporting organizations for the lighting of those fields? I
mean that’s a proposal you will have to make to the Administration
and we’ll take it under consideration. Storm Water Management
regulation and cleaning of trucks, the DPW is looking at that.
We certainly have had ongoing negotiations with the Board of Education
in terms of sharing services. You’re the liaison to the Board
of Education so you certainly are probably more aware of those
conversations then any other Council member on this dais this evening.
Recycling, I mean that is an unbelievable comment that you’ve
made. We have more recycling containers, thanks to Mr. Phil Tobey,
out at Mount Olive owned properties, buildings, recreational facilities,
than we have ever had in the history of Mount Olive Township. Mount
Olive Township was granted more money based on the recycling efforts
that we put forward, than any other municipality in Morris County
for 2007. We received more funds from the County than any of the
other 39 municipalities in Morris County based on our recycling
efforts. We have sent out fliers informing the residents of what
needs to be recycled. We’ve actually made, thanks to the
efforts of Mr. Tobey and the Solid Waste Advisory Committee, we
have made recycling a little bit easier. You no longer need to
tie up your magazines and newspapers with rope. You can now put
it in brown bags if that’s easier for you so we have the
option. I think we’ve already addressed the moving of the
fuel depot, and for some reason I don’t necessarily have
the answer Jim, but it was, I don’t think it was cost effective
and we’ve done the study. I’ll have Bill get some answers
for me in the next couple of days, but it wasn’t cost effective
for us to be able to share the fueling depots with the Board of
Education. DPW cost overrun. We’ve actually controlled the
cost of that project. That project went out at $1.9 million before
Bill and I ever came here for a building that was 30,000 square
feet. You now have a building that is only 20,000 square feet that
when we took office, I think our estimate was $2.4, in that neighborhood
to complete. So we’ve tried to reign in the cost and the
inability of previous individuals to control the cost and the completion
of that project. We think we’ve done that in a fairly responsible
manner. Absolutely when we get done with that project we will provide
you with the cost that it cost us to complete that project, including
the in-house manpower. Although it may be difficult to identify
what did not get done because of the responsibilities that our
employees have taken over with that project, we will try to the
best of our ability to identify what may not have gotten completed
based on the job we did there in-house. Glendale Avenue tennis
courts again, it’s a matter of prioritization and I will
certainly have a recommendation in my 2008 budget that I present
to the Council. Council can either adopt that budget, change that
budget, modify it up, modify it down, and if your priorities are
different than mine, my responsibility as Mayor and Bill’s
as the Business Administrator, is to facilitate the will of this
governing body. You know that’s really what we do. We’re
not the decision makers. We carry out the wishes of this governing
body. Performance appraisals of all employees. You’re not
going to get a performance appraisal for all of the employees from
Bill or myself, but you certainly will get a performance appraisal
for the people that we have sole responsibility over, and that
would include the department heads and supervisors that directly
report to us that are not covered by the Union. With that I’ll
say I appreciate these 18 points that you’ve brought to our
attention. I can tell you that we’ve been talking about them
amongst management and we will certainly have a more detailed recommendation
for the 2008 budget season. I know it’s only August but we
certainly are getting into the funny season.
Mr. Buell: Yes.
Mayor Scapicchio: And I’m done.
President Greenbaum: Mr. Tepper.
Mr. Tepper: I’m not going to go over all of the items. I
certainly believe that we ought to have a formal policy for our
department heads and middle managers. I think it’s just a
good practice to have. Fleet maintenance. I expect that we’re
going to see results as to what the cost was. I thought Blue Atlas
was part of the overall longer range for Open Space and Recreational
Master Plan. Recycling. I will concur with the Mayor that when
I was on Solid Waste, Phil was very active and involved. The County
Freeholders have recently approved a plan that increased recycling,
and Phil was a part of that as well. From a redevelopment of the
Lake, I believe that Mr. Greenbaum did bring someone in at one
point in time to talk about the possibility. I think Open Space,
Recreation, and overall plans on what we should do should be looked
at more on a long term basis rather than immediately reacting to
these things. I think that we’ll probably do that in 2008
as result of different committees being formed. I certainly think
we’ve all discussed during the School Board meetings the
Mr. Tepper (cont’d): fact that we wanted to see more shared
services. Personally, I would very much like to see the grounds
be taken over by the Township as I think we’ve got a great
staff and a great supervisor in Mr. Lynch. We could get that done
very efficiently but we also need the cooperation of the Board
of Education. I encourage us to actively look at any shared services
that we can do with the Board of Education to reduce the tax liability
to the residents of the Town. Thank you.
President Greenbaum: Mr. Buell anything further this evening?
Mr. Buell: No.
President Greenbaum: Okay. Any other Old Business? Any New Business?
We’re up to Legal Matters.
NEW BUSINESS - none
LEGAL MATTERS
Mr. Dorsey: Just a few things I’d like to mention so everyone
on the Council knows it. The sale of Combe Fill North proceeds.
The necessary complaint in rem tax foreclosure has now been filed
and the suit finalization of it will probably take about two months.
I had a call today from the attorney representing the purchaser
at the price of $10,000,051 and he advises me that since our last
conversation he has had a very successful fourth meeting with the
EPA in which they did not mention anything about a windfall profit
lien, and he’s had a very successful meeting with DEP relative
to their lien. I believe that they must be very close to the point
where DEP grants to them the permission to make the invasive testing,
which the only way I know how to say it is, test boring on that
track which will give us the critical results. So that seems to
move along very nicely. About ten days ago Bill Sohl brought to
my attention that he had received a copy of the letter from the
law firm of Fastner and Goldberg, or whatever their name is, representing
ARD to the DEP. ARD has apparently finally woken up to the fact
they, unlike Toll who three years ago immediately proceeded to
get a specific letter of exemption from Morris Chase from the DEP,
ARD did not do that. It has always been our position that we see
a very significant difference between ARD and the Toll Brothers
Development primarily because the ARD track, as we now refer to
it is heavily encumbered with wetlands, which is the primary reason
that it has not moved beyond a preliminary approval that was granted,
I don’t know, 18 or 19 years ago and infrastructure has not
been installed. I recognized almost a year ago that ARD would try
to enhance its position by boot strapping itself on to what Toll
has so aggressively pursued, and that’s the development of
their track. Well anyway, last February Toll appeared before our
Planning Board and making the best use I could of a non-lawyer
to play cross examiner at that meeting, I spoke with Mr. Tepper
and had him cross examine Mr. Kobert. I’m just going to read
it to you because it goes to the heart of the issue which ARD now
tries to raise.
Mr. Tepper: I have a couple of questions for Mr. Kobert. I just
want to make sure I understand from our last meeting, and since
the attorney from ARD is here also, these are being viewed as two
separate tracks. The ARD track and the Toll Brothers track i.e.
Morris Chase.
Mr. Kobert: I think that’s two separate approvals and two
separate tracks, yes. I think for purposes of certainty the extensions,
that’s how they’re treated, yes.
Mr. Tepper: So you’re here just asking for Toll Brothers
piece for phase one?
Mr. Kobert: That’s correct. (Mr. Dorsey: He gives him a
softball and he plays with it.)
Mr. Tepper: And that specifically excludes the phase one of what
would be ARD.
Mr. Kobert: That’s correct and in fact I can represent,
and just if you want to confirm it that Council for ARD is here
and Mr. Hobbes, who I don’t think knew what it was all about,
could probably confirm that as well.
Mr. Tepper: I do see Mr. Hobbes here. (Mr. Dorsey: He’s
now speaking for Mr. Hobbes) And I just wanted to confirm that
in my mind, and make sure I understood that even though Toll Brothers
has purchased that… (Mr. Dorsey: Kobert corrects him.) ..when
you say you entered into a contract…
Mr. Kobert: Entered into a contract. We have not closed.
Mr. Tepper: Okay, so they will be viewed as separate pieces. Phase
one of each is separate.
Mr. Dorsey: And that now is key, I think, to our opposition which
we will submit to DEP at the right moment to our position that
these two tracks are separate. They are distinct. Distinct approvals
granted, distinct differences in terms of their inherent developability,
etc. etc. We do not want to see ARD as a practical matter, Mr.
Dorsey (cont’d): ever obtain a DEP Highlands exemption, because
if they do that’ll put that property in play forever and
it simply shouldn’t be there. Thank you.
COUNCIL REPORTS
Recreation Liaison Report
Mr. Tobey: Nothing to report.
Board of Health Report
Mrs. Labow: We’re going to meet again in September but we
received a letter from Mr. Rattner this past week about the Phosphorous
Ordinance and I passed that on to our Health Officer as well as
our Board of Health attorney for review. So we should be able to
have some response on that shortcoming, coming shortly.
Planning Board Report
Mr. Tepper: Meets Thursday and ARD is up for hearing.
Board of Adjustment Liaison Report
Mr. Perkins: Nothing to report.
Open Space Committee Report
Mrs. Labow: We didn’t meet yet.
Legislative Committee Report
Mr. Perkins: That’s Mr. Buell.
President Greenbaum: Mr. Buell.
Mr. Buell: Nothing to report except that we’re meeting with
Cablevision about their contract on Thursday.
Pride Committee Liaison Report
Mr. Perkins: The SLAP group is down on Route 206 putting in the
mulch and the new sign is being designed and other beautification
projects are being designed.
Board of Education Liaison Report
Mr. Buell: Their next meeting is, I think, the 24th or 25th.
Lake/Environment Issues Committee
Mr. Rattner: Nothing to report.
Safety Committee Liaison
Mr. Perkins: No meeting.
Finance Committee Report
Mr. Rattner: As I reported earlier, we expect to meet probably
within the next week with everybody’s availabilities and
just set an appropriate time that the Administration representatives
can attend.
Economic Development Committee Report
Mr. Rattner: We took July off. Next meeting is in two weeks.
Solid Waste Advisory Committee Report
Mrs. Labow: We took the summer off we’re meeting in September.
Library Board Liaison
Mr. Tepper: Meets tomorrow.
President Greenbaum: At this point I’ll open it up to the
public. Is there anyone who wishes to be heard? Mr. Russell. Please
state your name and address.
PUBLIC PORTION
Nelson Russell, Budd Lake: I’d like to add item 19 to Jim’s
list, and that is weed control at the Lake. While we’re budgeting
I think that’s something that we’re going to be faced
with next year.
Mayor Scapicchio: It’s on the list.
Mr. Russell: Good.
President Greenbaum: Thank you. Mr. Ireland name and address please.
Scott Ireland, 6 Eric Court, Flanders: I was going to get up earlier
and make some acerbic remarks about the dog park, but as I got
my hand up the Council President shut down conversation in a very
un-American manner. I won’t pursue that any further. I do
have a comment about, or a question. Is the town responsible for
the grounds, exterior grounds over at the library?
Mr. Rattner: For the what?
President Greenbaum: Exterior grounds of the library.
Mr. Ireland: Maintenance of the grounds outside and around the
library.
President Greenbaum: In what context? Do we own the property?
Mr. Ireland: Do you maintain it in the sense of, well I went over
there…
President Greenbaum: I believe that the answer to the question
is that the Township does provide maintenance services to the library
in terms of cutting the grass.
Mr. Ireland: My only comment and observation is that I was there
about a week ago and the grass looks like crap. If we could just
invest in a little weed and feed. You have a $5 million building,
and right now because of the construction we have tall weeds, and
next time we’ll have short weeds. It looks terrible.
President Greenbaum: Certainly pass that along through the Business
Administrator to Jim Lynch.
Mr. Ireland: We only need some remediation on the grass.
President Greenbaum: Thank you very much. I’m going to have
to take a ride over to Mr. Ireland’s property to see how
his lawn looks.
Mr. Tepper: It’s magnificent.
President Greenbaum: Anyone else from the public? Yes sir, Mr.
Escobar. Please state your name and address for the record.
Rich Escobar, Woodsedge Avenue, Budd Lake: I’d just like
to make a comment. I think that if we don’t have policies,
procedures and evaluation points for the personnel that are being
evaluated, we could be in a problem. If we don’t have anything
documented to measure and therefore evaluate properly then it’s
all subjective, and I don’t know that that’s a good
thing.
President Greenbaum: Yes sir, were you here to bid on the property?
Jerry Corby, Summit Avenue, Budd Lake: The question is about that,
yes.
President Greenbaum: Yes, it was adjourned.
Mr. Sohl: It was cancelled.
President Greenbaum: It was cancelled.
Mr. Corby: Okay, I’m just curious as to how that occurred.
Mr. Dorsey: That was an Administrative decision that was made.
Mr. Corby: Okay, was there a, I mean it was on at the beginning
of last week, and it was off at the end of last week. I just wondered
how that occurred, and whether that can be reinstated.
Mr. Dorsey: We will certainly put you on the list and advise you
when that is reinstated. We have his name right?
Mr. Corby: Are you saying that it will be reinstated, or that
it can be?
Mr. Dorsey: Well I think that at some point it will be but not
next week. We’ll give you the summer off.
Mr. Corby: Okay thank you. Cancelled is different than postponed.
Thank you very much for your time
President Greenbaum: Thank you. Anyone else from the public? Seeing
none, I’ll close it to the public. Any final comments from
Council, or from anyone sitting up here?
COUNCIL COMMENTS
Mr. Tobey: I appreciate what the Mayor and Mr. Tepper said, but
I just want everyone to know the Solid Waste Committee as a whole
deserves the credit for what we’ve accomplished. That’s
all.
President Greenbaum: See, when I look at you Mr. Tobey though,
I just think of waste, I don’t know why.
Mr. Perkins: Thank you Mr. President, I just want to say quick
in my years of being up here, I know we have had numerous discussions
about what some used to be under, which was called management by
objectives, which provides a set of objectives and goals which
any self respective manager or supervisor or department head which
should be sitting down with their immediate superior coming up
jointly together with what their goals are for the quarter, for
the half year, for the three quarter and for the end of the year.
Those are the goals and objectives that they’re rated on.
The rating goes from one to five and wherever you fall on that
rating, you either met your goal or you didn’t. So you have
a sufficient reason why you haven’t met it. If you don’t
have a plan on where you’re going to be six months from now
then how do you ever know when you made it there? So that is something
that the Council has talked about, and we’ve talked about
it with other Administrations. I know that the Mayor and the Business
Administrator have thought about it. It is something that needs
to be done but exactly which one is the fairest? What is the most
equitable? I know Councilman Rattner and myself, quite some years
ago, came up with quite a few different MBO’s and other programs
that are out there for actually doing performance appraisals on
management staff. It’s a touchy subject. Yes, people are
in direct contact in this building. I know everyone pretty much
personally here and I can tell you that in my humble opinion, they’re
all doing an excellent job. However, there are some that I like
more than others. If it was up to me to hand out a raise, it’s
normally your best friend for the last two months and who you haven’t
seen for the last eight months who is up there telling you everything
that they have done, because they know the performance appraisal
time has come. So an effective performance appraisal needs to be
done, but it can’t be a one time at the end of the year deal.
You need to monitor, you need to help these individuals manage
the tremendously hard task that they have, and that’s the
only fair way to do it. Thank you Mr. President.
President Greenbaum: Thank you, Mr. Rattner?
Mr. Rattner: I just want to say that the Mount Olive Week or Weekend,
whatever it was, Fair, went very well. I also want to thank everybody
who supported the Kiwanis dunk tank. In the tank was me, Mr. Tepper,
Mr. Buell, and we had Mrs. Labow working the table. The Mayor was
in there and he had his prime time on Sunday, except that it got
rained out. I’ll tell you he cried for two days. He really
wanted to be in there and he got disappointed. To everyone that
supported it thank you very much, and hopefully a better Fair next
year.
President Greenbaum: Motion to adjourn.
Mrs. Labow: So moved.
Mr. Buell: Second.
ADJOURNMENT
Motion was made and seconded, all in favor and none opposed, the
meeting was adjourned at 9:05 pm.
_________________________________
Robert J. Greenbaum, Council President
I, LISA M. LASHWAY, Township Clerk of the Township of Mount Olive
do hereby certify that the foregoing Minutes is a true and correct
copy of the Minutes approved at a legally convened meeting of the
Mount Olive Township Council duly held on September 11, 2007.
______________________________________
Lisa M. Lashway, Township Clerk
jr
|